Physicists on the LHCb experiment at CERN's Large Hadron Collider have found the first evidence of a beauty particle decaying into two muons, a process the Standard Model says happens about once in every ten billion decays. The result, announced at a seminar at CERN and submitted to Physical Review X, comes in at 3.2 sigma.
Forty-two years of looking
The hunt started in 1984, when the CLEO experiment set the first upper limit on the rate. The particle in question, known as Bd, holds a beauty quark and a down antiquark and lives for about one and a half trillionths of a second. It almost always decays into something easier to see. The muon pair channel is rare enough that earlier experiments could only pile up limits, and a 2015 joint analysis by LHCb and CMS confirmed the related Bs decay while offering only hints of Bd.
The upgraded detector changed the arithmetic. Better trigger selection and improved muon identification let the team separate a handful of candidates from a background millions of times larger.
Why the number matters
The Standard Model predicts a branching fraction of about 1.03 per ten billion. Combined with older data, the measured value comes out at 1.14 per ten billion, with error bars that comfortably include the prediction. That agreement is the point: these decays are sensitive to particles that are not in the model, and any heavy new particle would shift the rate.
The measurement therefore narrows the room where new physics could hide, in the same family of processes that made Bs decays a testing ground for years.
Not a discovery yet
Five sigma is the threshold for claiming a discovery, and 3.2 sigma is short of it. More data from the current run should get the experiment closer, and the collaboration says the channel will become a standard part of its programme either way.
For now the result is a confirmation of a prediction made decades ago, obtained at the edge of what a single experiment can resolve, and a reminder that the Standard Model keeps surviving tests built to break it.